Hi Jordan, I directed Fiddler 3 years ago and my Tevye was 15 at the time. Since every married Jewish male in your cast will need a beard, you might want to look into actually bearding. Basically you buy theatrical hair and spirit gum and apply it on piece by piece. We had our make-up girls practice quite a bit before the show. The result is a very authentic looking beard as you can blend the colours of hair to add in grey for the older men. If you would like pictures or details let me know. SerenaRae